Our Story

Maggie’s Eatery is a classic American dine in and take-away restaurant located in beautiful, Miller Place, NY.  It is named after my late grandmother, Maggie, who had a big influence on me growing up and who always encouraged me (i.e., put me to work!) in the kitchen. 

Before my partner Molly Harry and I moved to Miller Place in 2021, I was Head Chef at both Indian Wells Restaurant in Amagansett and Bostwick’s On The Harbor in East Hampton, two very popular and successful seafood restaurants on the East End.

Our goal at Maggie’s Eatery is to provide simple, delicious meals for the whole family, made with the freshest ingredients, expertly prepared, and reasonably priced. 

Whether you are local or just visiting, a weekly regular or occasional diner, we thank you for checking us out and look forward to seeing you again. 



Edward & Margaret Hannibal, Wedding Day, Cambridge, MA, 1958

Maggie & Tyler, East Hampton, NY, 1995